Ammonia Reader Tested Updated May 2026

Turf Infill Ranked From Worst to Best for Pet Odor Control

Using ammonia readers, we tested how different infills respond to urine over time and how quickly ammonia odors develop. Based on real world performance, we ranked these infills from the worst to the best.

Ammonia reader tested Real pet households No sponsored rankings

Quick Rankings

6 Silica Sand Worst
5 Envirofill / Wonderfill Poor
4 OptiFill Poor
3 Zeolite Fair
2 CamoFill Fair
1 Infill X Best
Quick Answer

The best infill for pet odor control is Infill X — it eliminates odor at the source rather than absorbing or masking it. Ammonia testing consistently shows near-zero readings even under repeated urine exposure.

Silica sand is the worst option — it provides zero odor protection and ammonia readings rise quickly. Pet-marketed infills like Envirofill and Wonderfill saturate over time and fail.

Best Overall

Infill X

2.8 ppm ammonia reading

Runner Up

CamoFill

Delays odor longer

Avoid

Silica Sand

100 ppm ammonia reading

What Is Turf Infill and Why It Matters

Turf infill is the granular material installed between artificial grass blades after the turf is laid down. While it may look like simple sand or grit, infill plays a critical role in how turf performs and how long it lasts.

Without proper infill, artificial turf mats down quickly, shifts, overheats, and wears out prematurely. For pet turf, infill is even more important.

Blade Support

Infill helps turf blades stand upright, adds weight so the turf stays in place, and protects the backing from sun damage.

Drainage Support

Infill supports drainage so urine can pass through the turf system rather than pooling on the surface.

Impact Absorption

Infill absorbs impact from foot traffic and pets, protecting the turf backing and extending its lifespan.

Ammonia Prevention

The infill layer is the first material to interact with urine. If it cannot manage urine correctly, the turf will smell no matter how often it is rinsed.

Why Pet Turf Smells Like Ammonia

When a dog urinates on artificial turf, the liquid drains through the turf fibers and settles into the infill layer. That infill becomes the first material to interact with the urine.

As urine sits in the turf system, bacteria begin breaking it down. This process creates ammonia gas, which is responsible for the sharp sour smell many pet owners experience.

If the infill cannot manage urine correctly, the turf will smell no matter how often it is rinsed or sprayed. This is why choosing the correct infill is more important than any surface deodorizer.

Turf Infill Ranking From Worst to Best

Ranked by ammonia reader testing results

6 infills tested
Rank Infill Verdict
#6
Silica Sand Worst
#5
Envirofill / Wonderfill Poor
#4
OptiFill Poor
#3
Zeolite Based Infills Fair
#2
CamoFill Good
#1
Infill X Best

Turf Infill Ammonia Reading Results

Measured in parts per million (ppm) with ammonia readers

6 Silica Sand
Extreme 100.0
4 OptiFill
Extreme 100.0
2 CamoFill
Extreme 99.8
5 Envirofill / Wonderfill
Extreme 98.7
3 Zeolite
Severe 72.6
1 Infill X
Clean / Normal 2.8

Ammonia Scale Ranges

0-10 Clean / Normal
10-25 Noticeable
25-50 Strong
50-90 Severe
90+ Extreme

Individual Infill Reviews

Ranked #6 (worst) to #2 (good). Our #1 pick gets its own dedicated section below.

#6 Worst

Silica Sand

The Worst Turf Infill for Pets

Extreme 100.00 ppm

When dogs urinate on turf filled with silica sand, the urine drains into the sand and stays there. Ammonia readings on silica infill rise quickly and remain high even after rinsing or deodorizing.

Silica sand is the most commonly used turf infill and the worst option for pet environments. Silica sand was never designed for odor control. It does not neutralize urine, kill bacteria, or reduce ammonia. It does not even claim to. Its only purpose is weight and blade support.

Pros
  • + Weight and blade support
  • + Widely available
  • + Inexpensive
Cons
  • - Zero odor protection short term or long term
  • - Urine drains into sand and stays there
  • - Moisture builds up, bacteria multiply
  • - Ammonia forms rapidly
  • - Readings remain high even after rinsing or deodorizing

Ammonia Test Result

100.00 ppm Extreme Reading
#5 Poor

Envirofill and Wonderfill

Pet Marketed Infills That Fail Quickly

Extreme 98.70 ppm

Once saturated, odor releases back into the air and ammonia readings rise rapidly. Cleaning provides only temporary relief because the source of the odor remains trapped inside the infill.

Envirofill and Wonderfill are very similar mineral based infills often marketed as pet friendly. These infills rely on absorbing odor rather than eliminating it. Initially, this can appear effective. Over time, they become saturated with urine and stop working.

Pros
  • + Marketed as pet friendly
  • + May appear effective initially
  • + Slightly better than silica early on
Cons
  • - Become saturated with urine over time
  • - Stop working once saturated
  • - Odor releases back into the air
  • - Ammonia readings rise rapidly after saturation
  • - Cleaning provides only temporary relief
  • - Long term results are poor

Ammonia Test Result

98.70 ppm Extreme Reading
#4 Poor

OptiFill

Odor Issues Plus Tracking Problems

Extreme 100.00 ppm

OptiFill introduces an additional problem. Because it is color treated, the dye can sometimes transfer from the infill granules. This material can track into homes on shoes or dog paws, leaving residue on flooring and entry areas.

OptiFill is often presented as a premium pet infill, but real world performance shows consistent odor issues over time. Like CamoFill, OptiFill slows odor development initially but still allows ammonia buildup as urine exposure continues.

Pros
  • + Slows odor development initially
  • + Color treated appearance
Cons
  • - Ammonia readings rise steadily over time
  • - Turf odor returns despite maintenance
  • - Color dye can transfer from granules
  • - Tracks into homes on shoes or dog paws
  • - Leaves residue on flooring and entry areas
  • - Adds extra cleanup beyond odor issues

Ammonia Test Result

100.00 ppm Extreme Reading
#3 Fair

Zeolite Based Infills

Absorbs Odor but Does Not Eliminate It

Severe 72.60 ppm

Note: Zeolite also requires ongoing treatment to prevent unhealthy bacterial buildup. Once the pores fill with urine and ammonia, zeolite stops working.

Zeolite based infills are often considered an upgrade from basic infills because they absorb ammonia odors well at first. Turf with zeolite frequently smells fine when new. The problem is saturation.

Pros
  • + Absorbs ammonia odors well at first
  • + Considered an upgrade from basic infills
  • + Turf smells fine when new
Cons
  • - Saturation is inevitable
  • - Does not neutralize ammonia
  • - Does not stop bacterial growth
  • - When saturated, ammonia readings rise quickly
  • - Odors return suddenly
  • - Multi dog homes or warm climates saturate faster
  • - Requires ongoing treatment to prevent bacterial buildup

Ammonia Test Result

72.60 ppm Severe Reading
#2 Fair

CamoFill

Longer Lasting but Still Smells Over Time

Extreme 99.80 ppm

Note: CamoFill still relies on suppressing odor rather than destroying it. Over time, repeated urine exposure overwhelms the material and pet odors return.

CamoFill performs better than zeolite and delays odor longer. It represents a step forward in infill technology. Ammonia readings rise more slowly, and turf stays usable for a longer period.

Pros
  • + Performs better than zeolite
  • + Delays odor longer
  • + Step forward in infill technology
  • + Ammonia readings rise more slowly
  • + Turf stays usable for longer period
Cons
  • - Still relies on suppressing odor rather than destroying it
  • - Repeated urine exposure overwhelms the material
  • - Pet odors return over time

Ammonia Test Result

99.80 ppm Extreme Reading
#1 Ranked Infill
Best for Pet Odor Control
2.8 ppm Clean / Normal
Infill X — Self Deodorizing and Rechargeable Turf Infill
#1 Pick

Infill X

Self Deodorizing and Rechargeable Turf Infill

Best Turf Infill for Pets Short Term and Long Term

Infill X operates in a completely different category than every infill above. It is designed to eliminate odor at the source rather than absorb or mask it. Ammonia testing consistently shows clean and normal readings of 2.8 ppm.

This performance holds immediately after installation and long term under repeated urine exposure. Infill X does not go through a saturation phase where it suddenly fails weeks or months later.

Eliminates Odor at the Source

Infill X is designed to eliminate odor at the source rather than absorb or mask it. It activates when moisture touches it.

Neutralizes Ammonia Instantly

When urine enters the turf system, the infill immediately begins neutralizing ammonia and interrupting bacterial activity.

Zero Saturation Phase

Infill X does not go through a saturation phase where it suddenly fails weeks or months later like zeolite or other absorbent infills.

Rechargeable Technology

Instead of being removed and replaced, Infill X can be recharged through professional treatment and restored to near new performance.

Ammonia Reading Comparison

2.8

Infill X — Clean

100.0

Silica Sand — Extreme

Self Deodorizing Rechargeable Technology Zero Saturation Phase Ammonia Reader Tested

Understanding the Ammonia Scale

Common ammonia scale ranges used for testing

Click any bar to expand details

Actual Test Results by Infill Type

Infill X
Clean / Normal 2.8 ppm
Zeolite Based Infills
Severe 72.6 ppm
Envirofill / Wonderfill
Extreme 98.7 ppm
CamoFill
Extreme 99.8 ppm
Silica Sand
Extreme 100.0 ppm
OptiFill
Extreme 100.0 ppm

Proof of Ammonia Readers Testing Turf Infill

Watch the ammonia reader testing in action

Watch how we tested each infill type with ammonia readers to get accurate real-world measurements.

Maintenance Reality: What Each Infill Actually Requires

The infill you choose determines your maintenance burden for the next decade. Here is an honest schedule broken down by infill type — plus the three mistakes that undo every other good decision you made.

Weekly All infill types
  • Rinse the full turf area with water to flush urine concentration
  • Spot-check any areas where pets frequently urinate — groom with a stiff broom
Monthly Sand & zeolite installs
  • Apply enzyme cleaner for non-antimicrobial infills (silica sand, plain sand, zeolite)
  • Brush blades upright with a turf rake or stiff broom
  • Inspect drainage holes in the backing for blockage
Annually All infill types
  • Deep clean with diluted enzyme solution and full surface rinse
  • Evaluate infill depth — top up if below 1 inch from blade tips
  • Zeolite: assess saturation with a sniff test after a warm-day rain
Every 1–2 Years Zeolite & sand installs
  • Zeolite replacement if odor control has declined significantly
  • Sand infills: consider full professional deep clean or infill refresh

3 Maintenance Mistakes That Ruin Any Infill

1

Using bleach directly on turf

Why it fails: Degrades turf fiber UV stabilizers, voids most warranties, and kills beneficial microflora without solving bacterial root cause.

The fix: Use a diluted enzyme cleaner or purpose-formulated turf deodorizer instead.

2

Skipping rinsing after pet use

Why it fails: Concentrated urine sitting on the surface for 24+ hours allows ammonia to permeate infill particles and fiber backing.

The fix: Rinse within 24 hours of heavy use — a simple garden hose is sufficient.

3

Using a pressure washer

Why it fails: High pressure displaces infill unevenly, can break turf fiber, and compacts the base layer, damaging drainage.

The fix: Use a low-pressure hose or trigger nozzle at a downward angle.

Related Reading

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about turf infill and pet odor control

Pet turf odor problems are almost always infill problems. Surface sprays and enzymes may help temporarily, but they cannot fix the wrong infill underneath. If your turf smells, it is not your dog. It is the infill. The infill layer is the first material to interact with urine, and if it cannot manage urine correctly, the turf will smell no matter how often it is rinsed or sprayed.

Infill X is designed to eliminate odor at the source rather than absorb or mask it. It activates when moisture touches it. When urine enters the turf system, the infill immediately begins neutralizing ammonia and interrupting bacterial activity. Unlike zeolite or other absorbent infills, Infill X does not go through a saturation phase where it suddenly fails weeks or months later.

Like all materials, Infill X has a usable lifespan. The difference is how it is maintained. Instead of being removed and replaced, Infill X can be recharged through professional treatment and restored to near new performance. This eliminates infill tear out, excavation, and replacement costs while maintaining long term odor control.

Envirofill and Wonderfill rely on absorbing odor rather than eliminating it. Initially, this can appear effective. Over time, they become saturated with urine and stop working. Once saturated, odor releases back into the air and ammonia readings rise rapidly. Cleaning provides only temporary relief because the source of the odor remains trapped inside the infill.

Zeolite based infills absorb ammonia odors well at first, and turf with zeolite frequently smells fine when new. The problem is saturation. Once the pores fill with urine and ammonia, zeolite stops working. It does not neutralize ammonia or stop bacterial growth. When saturation occurs, ammonia readings rise quickly and odors return suddenly. In multi dog homes or warm climates, this can happen fast.

Yes. Silica sand is the most commonly used turf infill and the worst option for pet environments. It was never designed for odor control. It does not neutralize urine, kill bacteria, or reduce ammonia. When dogs urinate on turf filled with silica sand, the urine drains into the sand and stays there. Moisture builds up, bacteria multiply, and ammonia forms rapidly. Our testing showed ammonia readings of 100.00 ppm.

OptiFill is often presented as a premium pet infill, but real world performance shows consistent odor issues over time. OptiFill also introduces an additional problem. Because it is color treated, the dye can sometimes transfer from the infill granules. This material can track into homes on shoes or dog paws, leaving residue on flooring and entry areas. This adds extra cleanup and frustration beyond odor issues.

The Bottom Line

Pet turf odor problems are almost always infill problems. Surface sprays and enzymes may help temporarily, but they cannot fix the wrong infill underneath.

If your turf smells, it is not your dog. It is the infill.

Choosing the correct turf infill from the start is the difference between a yard that smells in weeks and one that stays fresh for years.

Based on our ammonia reader testing, Infill X is the clear winner with a reading of just 2.8 ppm (clean/normal), while every other infill tested in the severe to extreme range (72-100 ppm). Infill X eliminates odor at the source rather than absorbing or masking it, and it can be recharged through professional treatment rather than requiring full replacement.

#1 Ranked

Ready to Eliminate Pet Odor at the Source?

Shop Infill X — the only infill that eliminates odor rather than absorbing or masking it. Ammonia readings of 2.8 ppm vs 100+ ppm for other infills.

Eliminates odor at source
Rechargeable technology
Zero saturation phase
2.8 ppm ammonia reading
Free shipping on orders $150+ 30-day hassle-free returns Expert install guidance included